CUPE 3907 supports Post-Doctoral Fellows at McMaster University in their struggle for a fair settlement
On May 3, 2009, CUPE 3907 called on Provost Busch-Vishniac to negotiate a fair settlement for Post-Doctoral Fellows. Read the complete letter below:
252 Bloor Street West, Room 8-104
Toronto ON M5S 1V6
(416) 978-2403
Sent by email (hard copy to follow by mail)
May 3, 2009
Dr. Ilene Busch-Vishniac
Provost and Vice-President (Academic)
1280 Main Street West
University Hall, Room 201
Hamilton, Ontario
L8S4L8
Re: Concerns about treatment of PDF at the bargaining table
Dear Dr. Busch-Vishniac:
The members of CUPE local 3907 view McMaster University’s treatment of its
Post-Doctoral Fellows with grave concern for the principles of equity and the
institution’s commitment to developing the professional capacity of all of its
personnel.
McMaster University should be committed to substantive justice in the manner in
which it deals with its different stakeholders. However, this necessary principle
and practice does not appear to extend to Post-Doctoral Fellows. Your
bargaining team has proposed a base yearly full-time salary of $25,000, or about
$13.75 per hour for these academic workers. Beware that this scheme would
place Post-Doctoral Fellows at about $15,000 below the average wage level at
your institution. In The Global Competitiveness Report 2008/2009, Canada
ranked 20th out of 134 countries on the brain drain phenomenon. Given the low
wage rate that your organization is offering these academic workers, it is easy to
understand why skilled and professional Canadians are fleeing this country for
greener pastures.
McMaster’s proposal, to freeze wages for three years will not help in solving the
political problem of government underfunding and the enormous cost of
operating a postsecondary institution. Business organizations are trying to solve
their financial challenges on the backs of workers. Morally-speaking, this ought
not to be the path of an institution of higher learning such as McMaster
University. These academic workers are willing to accept a modest 2% wage
increase, which is 1% below the average wage settlement in the university
sector. This willingness to accept less than other workers in the postsecondary
sector should have been interpreted as a gesture to work with the university in
this difficult economic period. This group of academic workers deserves a better
response to their noble effort.
The provision of dental benefits, parental leave, professional development funds
and protection of intellectual property rights are not outside of the current practice
of McMaster University. Yet your bargaining team continues to deny equality of
condition to Post-Doctoral Fellows on the preceding workplace benefits or rights.
The Global Competitiveness Report ranked Canada 19th on the extent of staff
training on the “Higher education and training” pillar of global competitiveness.
McMaster University’s unwillingness to provide its Post-Doctoral Fellows with
adequate professional development funds will only contribute to Canada’s
unenviable ranking among highly industrialized states for staff training and
development. It is difficult to justify the treatment of Post-Doctoral Fellows like
second-class organizational “citizens”. Surely, you can do better at the
bargaining table.
CUPE Local 3907 fully supports the efforts of Local 3906 to negotiate a fair
settlement for Post-Doctoral Fellows at McMaster University. CUPE 3906 can
count on our local’s solidarity with the actions it takes to achieve substantive
organizational justice for Post-Doctoral Fellows at the bargaining table.
Sincerely,
Ajamu Nangwaya, Chair External
Cc: Dr. Allison Sekular – Dean of Graduate Studies
Ms. Lisa Newton, Legal Employee and Labour Relations
Brother Jesse Payne, Staff Representative, CUPE Local 3906
Sister Mary Ellen Campbell, President, CUPE Local 3906